Winter Sale | 17% OFF $19.95+ (Code: YBWS17) • 22% OFF $69.95+ (Code: YBWS22) 
HP 972A vs 972X: What’s the Difference?
Choosing the right ink cartridge for your HP PageWide Pro printer can significantly impact your printing costs and operational efficiency. The HP 972A and 972X cartridges may look similar at first glance, but understanding their key differences—especially in page yield, pricing, and cost per page—will help you make an informed decision. This guide breaks down both options to show you which one best fits your printing needs.
HP 972A vs 972X: Direct Comparison
| Feature | HP 972A | HP 972X |
|---|---|---|
| OEM Number | F6T80AN, L0R86AN, L0R89AN, L0R92AN | F6T84AN, L0R98AN, L0S01AN, L0S04AN |
| Ink Capacity | Standard Yield | High Yield |
| Printer Compatibility | PageWide Pro Series (e.g., 477dw, 577dw, 300, 400, 500) | PageWide Pro Series (e.g., 477dw, 577dw, 300, 400, 500) |
| Page Yield (ISO/IEC 24711) | Black: ~3,500 pages Color (C, M, Y): ~3,000 pages each | Black: ~10,000 pages Color (C, M, Y): ~7,000 pages each |
| Upfront Price (Approximate Retail) | Black: $96.99 Color (each): $110.99 CMYK 4-Pack: $469.56 | Black: $194.99 Color (each): $189.99 CMYK 4-Pack: $764.56 |
| Cost Per Page (CPP) | Black: 2.77¢ Color: 3.70¢ Avg. Full-Color: 3.76¢ | Black: 1.95¢ Color: 2.71¢ Avg. Full-Color: 2.47¢ |
| Best For | Lower to moderate print volume, tight upfront budgets, infrequent color printing, and new or unpredictable workflows. | High print volume, focus on Total Cost of Ownership, minimizing downtime, and reducing environmental impact. |
Compatible HP 972X Ink Cartridge Combo Pack of 4 – High Yield
- Get Crisp Prints and Vibrant Colors Every Time
- Only a Fraction of the Price of OEM Products
- Same-Day Shipping, Delivered Within 1-3 Business Days
- 30-Day Money Back Guarantee & 2-Year Warranty
- Sale Price: $149.95 (Subscribe to Get Extra 15% Discount)
HP 972A Ink vs HP 972X Ink: What They Have in Common
Before diving into the differences, it’s important to understand what makes these two cartridges similar. Both the HP 972A and 972X are genuine HP ink cartridges designed specifically for HP PageWide Pro series printers.
They share identical ink quality and formulation, ensuring consistent print results whether you choose the standard or high-yield option. The color accuracy, drying time, and overall print performance are identical between the two variants.
Both cartridge types are compatible with the same range of HP PageWide Pro printers, including popular models like the PageWide Pro 477dw, 577dw, 300, 400, and 500 series. They also share the same physical design and installation process—if your printer accepts one, it will accept the other without any modifications or adjustments needed.
Essentially, you’re choosing between different sizes of the same premium product, much like selecting between a standard and a large bottle of your favorite beverage.
HP 972A vs 972X: What’s the Difference?
Page Yield: Volume Comparison
The most significant difference between HP 972A and 972X cartridges lies in their page yield capacity.
Page yield refers to the estimated number of pages you can print with each cartridge, based on ISO/IEC 24711 testing standards.
| Cartridge Type | Black Cartridge Yield | Color Cartridge Yield (Each) | Total 4-Pack Potential Yield |
| HP 972A | 3,500 pages | 3,000 pages | Approximately 12,500 pages |
| HP 972X | 10,000 pages | 7,000 pages | Approximately 31,000 pages |
The HP 972A cartridges offer a solid yield for regular office use, with the black cartridge producing approximately 3,500 pages and each color cartridge (cyan, magenta, and yellow) yielding about 3,000 pages. This capacity is suitable for many small to medium offices with consistent but moderate printing needs. When considering a complete 4-pack, the total potential yield reaches approximately 12,500 pages, assuming balanced color usage.
In contrast, the HP 972X cartridges are designed for high-volume environments. The black cartridge provides an impressive 10,000 pages—nearly three times the yield of the 972A. The color cartridges similarly outperform their standard counterparts, each offering 7,000 pages, which is more than double the capacity of the 972A color cartridges. A complete 4-pack of 972X cartridges delivers approximately 31,000 pages of total printing potential. This substantial difference means the 972X cartridges will last significantly longer before needing replacement, directly impacting how frequently you’ll need to change cartridges and how much time you’ll spend on printer maintenance.
Pricing Analysis
The following table breaks down the upfront cost of each cartridge option, providing a clear comparison of initial investment requirements:
| Cartridge Type | Black Cartridge Price | Color Cartridge Price (Each) | CMYK 4-Pack Price |
| HP 972A | $96.99 | $110.99 | $469.56 |
| HP 972X | $194.99 | $189.99 | $764.56 |
At first glance, the 972X appears to be more expensive—and it is, in terms of upfront cost. The HP 972X black cartridge costs approximately twice as much as the 972A version, while the color cartridges are about 70% more expensive. The complete 4-pack represents a substantial investment difference of nearly $300. However, to truly understand the value proposition, we need to look beyond the sticker price and consider what you’re actually getting for your money in terms of page yield.
Cost Per Page: The Real Value Metric
The most important metric for evaluating printing costs is cost per page (CPP). This calculation reveals which cartridge offers better long-term value by breaking down the price to what you pay for each printed page. The following table illustrates the dramatic difference in operating costs:
| Cost Per Page Metric | HP 972A | HP 972X | Savings with 972X |
| Black Printing | 2.77¢ | 1.95¢ | 30% |
| Color Printing (Per Color) | 3.70¢ | 2.71¢ | 27% |
| Average Full-Color Printing | 3.76¢ | 2.47¢ | 34% |
For the HP 972A, the cost per page breaks down to 2.77 cents for black printing and 3.70 cents for each color. When printing full-color documents using all four cartridges, the average cost per page is approximately 3.76 cents.
The HP 972X delivers significantly better value on this crucial metric. Black printing costs just 1.95 cents per page—a 30% savings compared to the 972A. Color printing costs 2.71 cents per page for each color, representing a 27% reduction in cost. For full-color printing, the average cost drops to just 2.47 cents per page, which is 34% more economical than the 972A option.
These savings come from the economies of scale inherent in purchasing larger quantities. While the initial investment is higher, the cost per printed page decreases substantially, making the 972X the clear winner for anyone concerned with long-term printing expenses.
When HP 972A Makes Sense?
- Low to Moderate Printing Volume: Ideal for offices printing fewer than 1,000 pages monthly. The smaller capacity matches typical usage without ink sitting unused for extended periods.
- Budget-Constrained Purchasing: Perfect for businesses that need to manage cash flow carefully, as the lower initial cost reduces financial pressure.
- Infrequent Color Printing: Best when most printing is black and white, preventing color ink from expiring before full use.
- New or Variable Workflows: Suitable for establishing printing patterns without committing to large upfront investments.
When HP 972X Is the Better Choice?
- High-Volume Printing Environments: Essential for offices regularly producing thousands of pages monthly, significantly reducing cartridge change frequency.
- Total Cost of Ownership Focus: Delivers measurable financial benefits through 34% lower color printing costs that accumulate over time.
- Minimized Downtime Requirements: Perfect for busy offices where fewer cartridge changes mean increased productivity and reduced workflow interruptions.
- Environmental Considerations: Represents a more sustainable choice by reducing packaging waste and transportation emissions through fewer cartridge purchases.
Wrap It Up
The choice between HP 972A and 972X ultimately depends on your specific printing needs, budget, and operational priorities. For most business users with high and consistent printing volumes, the HP 972X offers significant advantages in terms of cost savings and convenience. However, for users with lower printing volumes, limited budgets, or situations where ink cartridges may sit idle for extended periods, the HP 972A remains a practical and sensible option. Both cartridges deliver the same high-quality HP printing performance; your choice should be based on which capacity option best suits your actual printing habits and financial situation.
