Brother TN920 vs TN920XL, Which One Should I Buy?
If you’re shopping for toner cartridges for your Brother printer, you may have come across two very similar options: the Brother TN920 and the Brother TN920XL. Like TN830 vs TN830XL, while both cartridges are designed for similar models of Brother printers, they do have some differences. In this blog, we’ll explore the Brother TN920 vs TN920XL to help you decide which toner cartridge is the best value for your money.
Brother TN920 vs TN920XL Quick View
Specifications | Brother TN920 | Brother TN920XL |
Color Option | Black Toner Cartridge | |
Appearance | Same Size and Design | |
Shelf Life | 24-36 Months | |
Printer Compatibility | Brother HL-EX415DW, HL-L5210DN, HL-L5210DW, HL-L5210DWT, HL-L5215DW, HL-L6210DW, HL-L6210DWT, HL-L6217DW, HL-L6310DW, HL-L6415DW, HL-L6415DWT, DCP-L5510DN, MFC-EX915DW, MFC-L5710DN, MFC-L5710DW, MFC-L5715DW, MFC-L5717DW, MFC-L5915DW, MFC-L6810DW, MFC-L6915DW | |
Print Quality | Produces High-Quality Black-and-White Prints | |
Cartridge Capacity | Standard Yield | High Yield |
Page Yield | 3,000 Pages | 6,000 Pages |
Cartridge Price | $82.49 | $110.49 |
Cost Per Page | $0.03 Per Page | $0.02 Per Page |
Both the Brother TN920 and TN920XL black toner cartridges are high-quality cartridges that are compatible with a wide range of Brother printers. The main differences are their page yields and cost-effectiveness.
The TN920XL has a higher page yield and is more expensive. If your printing needs are modest, the TN920 is an affordable choice. However, for users who print more, the Brother TN920XL can provide long-term savings by replacing toner less frequently and reducing your cost per page.

Compatible Brother TN920XL Toner Cartridge (TN-920XL) – With Chip – High Yield
- 30-Day Money Back Guarantee & 2-Year Warranty.
- Save More than 65% Compared to OEM TN920XL.
- With Upgraded IC Chips. No Toner Error Fixed.
- Fast Delivery within 1-3 Business Days.
- Sale Price: $38.50 (Cost Per Page: 0.64 cents)
TN920 and TN920XL: What Do They Have in Common?
Before we dive into the differences, let’s take a closer look at the features that Brother TN920 and TN920XL toner cartridges have in common.
Size and Design
Both the Brother TN-920 and TN-920XL are designed to work seamlessly with Brother’s range of high-performance laser printers.
In terms of physical dimensions, the two cartridges are almost identical. They are both black toner cartridges that work with a wide range of Brother printer models, ensuring hassle-free installation.
Print Quality
The TN920 TN920XL cartridges deliver the same print quality. They both produce sharp text and high-quality images. Whether you’re printing documents for professional or personal use, you’ll get vivid, detailed black-and-white prints. They use the same technology to produce prints, giving you consistent quality throughout use.
Shelf Life
Both the TN920 and TN920XL black toner cartridges have a shelf life of 24 to 36 months. Whether you choose the standard or XL version, you have plenty of time to store your cartridges before they expire.
Compatible Printers
Another similarity between the TN920 and TN920XL is compatibility. Both ink cartridges are compatible with the same models of Brother printers.
These include Brother HL-EX415DW, HL-L5210DN, HL-L5210DW, HL-L5210DWT, HL-L5215DW, HL-L6210DW, HL-L6210DWT, HL-L6217DW, HL-L6310DW, HL-L6415DW, HL-L6415DWT, DCP-L5510DN, MFC-EX915DW, MFC-L5710DN, MFC-L5710DW, MFC-L5715DW, MFC-L5717DW, MFC-L5915DW, MFC-L6810DW, MFC-L6915DW.

TN920 vs TN920XL: What Are the Differences?
Let’s explore the key differences between the Brother TN 920 and TN 920XL toner cartridges.
Different Page Yield
One of the most notable differences between the TN920 and TN920XL is their page yields. Page yield is the number of pages you can expect each cartridge to print before it needs to be replaced.
The standard-yield Brother TN920 can print 3,000 pages, and the high-yield Brother TN920XL can print 6,000 pages. If you print a lot, page yield is an important consideration. The higher the page yield, the fewer times you need to replace cartridges, which means more convenience and less frequent purchases.
For example, if you print about 500 pages per month, the TN920 will last about 6 months, while the TN920XL will last about 12 months. If you’re looking to reduce replacements and improve overall efficiency, it may be more advantageous to go with the TN920XL.
Different Toner Cartridge Price
Another difference between the two black toner cartridges is their price. The Brother TN920 toner cartridge costs $82.49, while the Brother TN920XL toner cartridge costs $110.49. The TN920XL is more expensive, but this cost increase is justified because its page yield is significantly higher. Essentially, you pay more upfront, but you get more toner that lasts longer.
Different Cost per Page
To really understand which cartridge is better value for money, it’s important to compare the cost per page, which is an important metric when evaluating price/performance. The lower the cost per page, the greater the long-term benefits. This is where the high yield Brother TN920XL demonstrates its efficiency.
Specifications | Brother TN920 | Brother TN920XL |
Page Yield | 3,000 Pages | 6,000 Pages |
Cartridge Price | $82.49 | $110.49 |
Cost Per Page | $0.03 Per Page | $0.02 Per Page |
As you can see, while the Brother TN920XL black toner cartridge has a higher initial cost, it has a lower cost per page. If you print a lot, the TN920XL is a more cost-effective choice in the long run.
Over time, the savings in cost per page will add up, and if you print thousands of pages per year, then the TN920XL is a more economical choice.
Brother TN920 vs TN920XL: Which One to Choose?
Which Brother toner cartridge should you choose? That depends on your print volume and your cost goals.
If your printing needs are relatively low or medium, the Brother TN920 standard yield toner cartridge is your best option. It provides high-quality printing at a more affordable cost, making it a good choice for individuals or small businesses who print less.
However, if you print frequently or in large quantities, the Brother TN920 XL high yield toner cartridge may be a better choice. With lower cost per page, it’s ideal for businesses or individuals who want to reduce the hassle of frequent toner changes and maximize printing efficiency.

Wrap It Up
Both the Brother TN920 and TN920XL are reliable toner cartridges that deliver high-quality prints and excellent shelf life. Which one to buy depends on your print volume and long-term budget considerations. If you print low volumes and want to spend less, buy the TN920. If you print a lot, the TN920XL may offer long-term cost savings and fewer replacements.